A screenshot stopped me while I was scrolling recently.
An Israeli commentator was making a familiar historical argument. Jews are a tiny part of the world’s population, yet they have repeatedly been accused of causing disasters far beyond their numbers or power. Beneath his words was a graphic carrying the phrase: “Old conspiracy. New packaging.”
It moved from earlier antisemitic accusations to the politics of our own time.

I understood the point immediately. History gives it considerable support.
But the final part bothered me.
There is a documented history of Jews being blamed for catastrophes they did not cause. It does not follow that criticism directed at Israel today belongs automatically to the same tradition. If we merge those two questions, we learn very little about either antisemitism or Israel.
When disease needed a culprit
During the Black Death of the fourteenth century, Europeans confronted a disease they could neither see nor explain. Jewish communities were accused of poisoning wells and spreading the plague.
The accusation was false.
The United States Holocaust Memorial Museum describes these plague accusations as part of a much longer history in which Jews became targets during periods of social upheaval.
What interests me is how useful the accusation became.
Disease is frightening enough. Disease without an explanation is worse. Medieval Europeans did not understand bacteria, fleas or the transmission of plague as modern medicine does. A rumour about poisoned wells gave frightened people something much easier to understand: somebody had done this to them.
That somebody could then be punished.
The same habit appeared in different forms much later.
After Germany’s defeat in the First World War, nationalists promoted the false claim that Germany had been betrayed from within. Jews became one of the principal targets. Nazi propaganda eventually stretched the conspiracy still further. Jews could supposedly stand behind international finance while simultaneously advancing communism.
Those claims contradicted each other.
They did not need to make sense together. They needed an enemy.
COVID showed how little the mechanism had changed
I remember the first months of COVID-19 and the extraordinary speed at which explanations appeared online.
Some were merely mistaken. Others required villains.
The United Nations recorded antisemitic conspiracy theories during the pandemic. It also documented hostility towards other communities, including Muslims, migrants and people of Asian descent.
Some antisemitic narratives claimed Jews had created the virus or intended to profit from it.
I found the resemblance to the plague accusations difficult to miss. Medieval Europeans imagined poisoned wells. People centuries later had laboratories, vaccines and international organisations around which to construct new suspicions.
COVID also complicates the argument in the screenshot. Jews were not the only people blamed.
The identity of a scapegoat depends partly on where the crisis occurs and which prejudices already exist there. Fear alone does not select its target. People draw upon stories they have already heard about outsiders.
Then I thought about Karachi
This history can feel distant when it begins with medieval Europe. It became less distant when I looked at my own city.
Karachi once had a Jewish community large enough to leave a physical mark on its streets.
Dawn has reported that roughly 2,500 Jews lived in Karachi before Partition. Many belonged to the Bene Israel community. Jewish residents worked in trades and professions, and some participated in civic life.
Abraham Reuben, for example, served on the Karachi Municipal Corporation in the 1930s.
More striking was the Magain Shalome Synagogue.
It was built in Ranchore Lines in 1893. For decades it served Karachi’s Jewish residents. The synagogue remained after Pakistan came into existence, although the community around it became progressively smaller.
The building was eventually demolished in 1988.
I have lived with Karachi’s crowded geography for years, yet the thought still catches me. A synagogue once stood in this city. Jewish families prayed there. Their children grew up here. People worked, traded and participated in the affairs of Karachi.
Now the building is gone, and the community has almost vanished from the city’s public memory.
I do not want to force that disappearance into a convenient explanation. History rarely gives us one.
Partition changed Karachi dramatically. The creation of Israel changed the political environment for Jewish communities across parts of the Muslim world. Wars in the Middle East added another layer of hostility and insecurity. Migration also fed migration as communities became smaller and institutions harder to sustain.
What remains particularly interesting in Pakistan is what happened afterward.
The Jewish presence became extremely small. Ideas about Jews did not disappear.
For many Pakistanis today, knowledge about Jewish people does not come from having Jewish neighbours or colleagues. It may arrive through religious discussion, Middle Eastern politics, imported conspiracy theories or social media.
A community can become almost invisible while stories about that community continue circulating.
The screenshot takes one step too far
The historical examples in the graphic are useful precisely because the accusations were directed against Jews collectively.
The contemporary Middle East presents a different problem.
Israel is a state. Its government makes decisions. Its military carries out operations. Those decisions can be examined in the same way we examine decisions made by Pakistan, Iran, India or the United States.
Criticising an Israeli government’s conduct does not make a person antisemitic.
The Nexus Document addresses this distinction directly. It argues that criticism of Israel, including severe criticism, should not automatically be treated as antisemitism.
The Jerusalem Declaration on Antisemitism makes a similar distinction while recognising that discussion of Israel can become antisemitic in particular circumstances.
The difference often appears in whom we hold responsible.
If someone criticises an Israeli prime minister, cabinet or military decision, the object of criticism is identifiable.
If the argument changes to “the Jews” being responsible, something else has happened.
The same problem appears when familiar claims about secret Jewish control of banks, governments or media are inserted into an argument about Israel. At that point we are no longer examining the actions of a government. We have returned to ideas that existed long before the modern State of Israel.
I also think the distinction has to work in the other direction.
Calling every severe criticism of Israel antisemitic weakens the term. It can also make genuine antisemitism harder to recognise when it appears.
A government should answer for what it does. A worldwide religious and ethnic population cannot sensibly be made answerable for that government’s actions.
Why blaming a group can become politically useful
A minority does not become a target merely because it is small.
There usually has to be a story already available about it.
Perhaps its members are described as disloyal. Perhaps they supposedly possess hidden wealth or influence. Perhaps their religion makes them appear permanently foreign.
Then something goes wrong.
An economy contracts. A war is lost. Disease spreads. Political institutions fail to provide convincing answers.
Complex explanations demand patience. They may involve policy mistakes stretching back years, institutional failures and forces that no individual controls. Conspiracy thinking removes much of that difficulty by assigning intention to the disaster.
Someone wanted this to happen.
Once people accept that proposition, finding an enemy becomes easier.
Social media did not invent this habit. It gave the habit extraordinary speed.
A rumour that once travelled from one European town to another can now cross continents in minutes. An old accusation can acquire a new photograph, a current political event and a hashtag before most people encounter the evidence needed to challenge it.
Pakistan cannot leave this history in Europe
Antisemitism is often taught as European history.
There are good reasons for that. Christian antisemitism developed over centuries in Europe, and Nazi Germany eventually turned racial antisemitism into a programme of mass murder.
Pakistan inherited a different historical landscape.
But ideas cross borders much more easily than people do.
Claims that Jews secretly control international finance, governments or the media did not originate in Pakistan. That does not prevent them from circulating here.
Neither should the existence of antisemitism prevent Pakistanis from talking about Palestinians.
Palestinian suffering does not become imaginary because antisemites exploit the conflict. Israeli policies remain open to examination. So do decisions made by Palestinian political organisations and armed groups.
The harder task is to resist turning political responsibility into inherited responsibility.
I keep returning to the Karachi part of this story.
A Jewish community once lived in this city. It built a synagogue and participated in municipal life. The synagogue is gone. The community has almost disappeared from our public memory.
Yet ideas about Jews have not disappeared with them.
Perhaps that is the part of the screenshot worth sitting with for a while. People do not have to know a minority before they learn to distrust it. Sometimes they know remarkably little about the people themselves. What they know is the story circulating about them.
I would criticise an Israeli government when the evidence warrants criticism. Governments must answer for their decisions. I would not make a Jewish family in London, New York or anywhere else answer for those decisions.
Keeping those positions separate should not be particularly difficult.
Our political arguments increasingly suggest otherwise.
2 thoughts on “The Scapegoat Pattern: Why Minorities Become Targets in Times of Crisis”