Pakistani business payment passing from a Pakistani bank through a correspondent bank toward a beneficiary bank, where the payment is stopped

Why International Payments from Pakistan Get Stopped or Returned

Your Pakistani bank approved the transfer. A correspondent bank may still hold it, and the beneficiary may not receive the money. Here is how to find out what happened.

A Karachi importer pays a supplier in Germany. His bank checks the invoice and contract. The account is debited, and the payment instruction goes out.

Two days later, the supplier calls. The money has not arrived.

The importer contacts his Pakistani bank. He is told that the payment has already been sent. How can both statements be true?

I spent years working with SWIFT and cross-border payments. One distinction matters more than most customers realise: a bank sending a payment instruction is not the same as the beneficiary receiving the money.

Several financial institutions may handle a transfer before it reaches the final account. Each has responsibilities that the customer rarely sees. When a payment goes missing, the first job is to establish where it stopped.

Your Pakistani bank has approved the payment. What happens next?

An outward commercial remittance from Pakistan begins with the rules issued by the State Bank of Pakistan. The bank must identify the relevant foreign-exchange provision, examine the supporting documents and complete its compliance checks. The SBP Foreign Exchange Manual provides the principal regulatory framework.

For many commercial payments, Chapter 14 is relevant. A bank may establish that a payment is permitted under Pakistan’s foreign-exchange regulations. That decision does not bind every foreign institution that later handles the transfer.

A correspondent bank in another country may apply different legal requirements. The beneficiary bank must also decide whether it can credit the account. The Pakistani bank’s approval is important. It is not the end of the process.

For the domestic regulatory stage, see our Chapter 14 guide and guide to SBP business-payment requirements.

Why correspondent banks become involved

A Pakistani bank cannot maintain direct settlement relationships with every bank in the world. It may use an account with a correspondent bank to move funds in a particular currency.

Pakistani customer → Pakistani bank → correspondent bank → foreign beneficiary bank

Some payments involve additional intermediaries. Others follow a more direct route. A correspondent bank is not merely forwarding an electronic message. It may handle settlement through accounts maintained between financial institutions, and it has legal obligations of its own.

The US banking regulators’ BSA/AML examination manual explains the risks associated with funds transfers. Payment instructions and the movement of funds are related, but not identical.

Four different things can happen to a payment

Customers often use the word stuck for every payment that fails to arrive. Banking operations require more precise language.

  • Delayed or under review: A bank is still processing the payment or seeking information.
  • Rejected: A bank has declined to process or credit the payment.
  • Returned: Funds are being sent, or have been sent, back through the banking chain.
  • Blocked: Funds or property may be frozen under an applicable sanctions requirement.

These outcomes are not interchangeable. A correspondent asking for an invoice has not necessarily rejected the transaction. A beneficiary bank refusing to credit an account does not automatically mean the funds have been blocked under sanctions law.

A returned payment may also arrive back at the originating bank with deductions or exchange-rate differences. The customer needs the actual status before deciding what to do next.

Why a foreign bank may stop a genuine payment

Imagine a Pakistani manufacturer buying machinery parts from an overseas supplier. The invoice is genuine, the contract is properly signed and the Pakistani bank has accepted the transaction.

A foreign correspondent may still ask why the beneficiary’s name differs from the supplier named in the contract. Perhaps the supplier uses a separate company to collect payments. That arrangement might be legitimate, but the foreign bank needs an explanation.

Another payment may attract attention because the beneficiary’s name resembles a name in sanctions-screening data. Sometimes the payment purpose is too vague. ‘Consultancy services’ gives a reviewing bank little information. A more precise description tied to a genuine contract may help it understand the transaction.

A request for additional information does not prove wrongdoing. Banks examine the jurisdictions involved and the underlying commercial activity. The same payment may face different checks depending on its route.

The US Treasury’s sanctions guidance distinguishes transactions that must be blocked from those that must be rejected. The applicable rule depends on the transaction and the institutions involved.

Can SWIFT stop your payment?

Customers sometimes say that SWIFT has held their money. That description usually confuses the messaging network with the banks handling the funds.

SWIFT provides secure financial messaging infrastructure. Banks use it to exchange payment instructions and related information. SWIFT does not itself hold the customer’s deposit or settle the payment between bank accounts.

The actual transfer of value occurs through correspondent banking arrangements or payment and settlement systems. A correctly formatted SWIFT message may reach another bank even when that bank subsequently delays or rejects the transaction. The message has travelled. The payment has not necessarily been completed.

How to trace a payment using its UETR

A useful investigation begins with the Unique End-to-end Transaction Reference, usually called the UETR. It is a 36-character identifier used to track a payment through the SWIFT chain. It helps banks locate the transaction; it does not guarantee completion.

SWIFT’s payment-tracking and confirmation services help participating institutions report a transaction’s progress and status. Ask your Pakistani bank for the UETR and request a payment-status investigation.

A customer may receive a copy of the payment instruction, depending on bank procedures. An MT103 or its ISO 20022 equivalent can provide transaction details, but a message copy alone does not establish that the beneficiary has been credited.

Ask whether the beneficiary bank has confirmed credit or whether the payment has only been transmitted.

If the payment is under review, ask which institution has requested information and what response is outstanding. If it has been rejected or returned, ask whether the bank has received the reason and whether the funds have begun their return journey.

Not every customer can access a bank’s tracking system directly. The originating bank is normally the appropriate starting point.

Six questions to ask your Pakistani bank

  1. Has the payment instruction actually been transmitted?
  2. What is the UETR?
  3. What status does the bank’s tracking or investigation system show?
  4. Has a correspondent or beneficiary bank requested additional information?
  5. Has the payment been rejected, returned or placed under review?
  6. If funds are returning, what deductions or exchange-rate effects may apply?

Ask the bank to distinguish a confirmed fact from an assumption. ‘We sent the payment’ answers one question. ‘The beneficiary bank confirmed credit’ answers another.

Why tracking does not solve every problem

SWIFT tracking has improved the visibility of international transfers. Yet visibility and control are different. A bank may establish where a payment is being processed without having the authority to compel another institution to release it.

The receiving bank may need further documents. A sanctions restriction may require a legal process rather than an ordinary operational correction. Some delays arise after the payment reaches the beneficiary bank, when local processing or account-crediting requirements remain outstanding.

Better payment data can help banks investigate these cases. It cannot remove every legal obligation in the chain.

Can a Pakistani business complain?

Start with the originating bank’s complaint management unit if the bank fails to investigate or explain the problem. Keep the transaction reference, copies of correspondence and the dates of each follow-up.

The State Bank of Pakistan’s consumer-protection information explains the complaint process. International remittance complaints may fall within the Banking Mohtasib Pakistan’s remit, subject to the applicable procedure. The customer generally needs to approach the bank first.

A complaint can address failures by the Pakistani bank in handling or investigating the transaction. It does not automatically give Pakistani authorities control over a foreign correspondent bank.

If the payment has not yet left Pakistan, read our separate guide to why Pakistani banks delay foreign payments.

What businesses can do before the next transfer

Check that the beneficiary details match the commercial documents. If a different company will receive the money, establish why and document the arrangement before sending the payment.

Give the bank a meaningful description of the payment purpose. Confirm the applicable SBP requirements before agreeing to a short overseas payment deadline. Ask whether the destination or route presents known processing difficulties.

A payment that arrives late can damage a commercial relationship even when every party has acted in good faith. Businesses should leave time for compliance questions rather than assume that transmitting an instruction completes the transaction.

The question I would ask first

When an importer tells me that his bank sent the money but the supplier has not received it, I would not begin by blaming SWIFT. I would ask for the payment’s UETR.

Then I would want to know the last confirmed status, which institution reported it and whether the bank has received an outstanding information request. The payment may be moving normally. It may be under investigation. It may already be returning.

Each situation requires a different response. For a customer in Karachi, the screen may show only a debit. Somewhere farther along the banking chain, another institution is making a decision that determines whether the supplier receives the funds.

Knowing where that decision sits is the beginning of a useful investigation.

Official and institutional sources

Regulatory note: This article explains international payment procedures for educational purposes. It is not legal, sanctions or transaction-specific banking advice. The treatment of a payment depends on its facts and the rules governing the institutions involved.

Explore more in the Pakistan Cross-Border Payments Guide.

Leave a Reply