A smartphone displaying suspicious card-payment alerts beside a bank card and complaint file on a desk in Karachi.

Pakistan Wants a Cashless Economy. Why Did I Have to Turn to a Foreign Company for My Refund?

Seven unauthorized credit-card transactions, an overseas merchant’s refund and the questions my Pakistani bank left unanswered.

On 28 August 2026, my phone began showing credit-card transaction alerts.

First came a charge of $10. Then $18. More followed, including several payments of $28.

Within roughly ten minutes, seven transactions totalling $158 had been authorized under the merchant name OPENAI. An eighth attempt for $28 was declined.

I had authorized none of them.

My regular ChatGPT Plus subscription had already been paid on 17 August. I checked my account and found nothing that explained the new charges.

I blocked my card and contacted my Pakistani bank.

I expected the bank to investigate the disputed payments and explain how they had been authorized. I raised complaints, but the responses did not resolve my concerns.

I then contacted OpenAI.

On 1 September, OpenAI informed me that it had located the disputed charges and processed a full refund. The company said the credit could take five to ten business days to appear.

I was relieved.

Still, I found the experience troubling. The foreign merchant had acted to return my money, while my dealings with the bank that issued my card had left important questions unanswered.

I had spent years working with international banking transactions. Now I was experiencing the payment system from the other side, as a customer trying to understand where his money had gone.

Pakistan Is Moving Towards Digital Payments

On 6 November 2026, Prime Minister Shehbaz Sharif directed officials to prepare a roadmap for establishing a fully digital payment system in Pakistan.

He wanted specific targets and deadlines. He also instructed officials to resolve problems faced by digital-payment users.

The government is treating the cashless economy as a national priority.

There has been measurable progress.

According to the Finance Division’s announcement on 12 November, the number of active merchants accepting digital payments had increased from 500,000 to 2.03 million.

Raast QR codes have appeared on utility bills. Government departments are introducing digital collection systems, while banks are being encouraged to expand payment facilities.

On 13 November, the Minister of State for Finance met senior banking executives in Karachi to discuss the next stage of the initiative.

I support the move towards electronic payments.

Cash is expensive to handle. It creates problems for record-keeping and can make it easier for parts of the economy to remain undocumented.

Digital payments also reduce the need for businesses to carry large amounts of cash.

But I worry about the government’s emphasis on adoption targets.

A merchant accepting a QR payment is one measure of progress. A customer recovering money after an unauthorized transaction is another.

The second receives much less public attention.

Pakistan cannot assume that wider access to digital payments will automatically produce greater trust in the institutions operating them.

I previously examined the scale of this transition in Pakistan Has Become a Digital-Payments Economy. Has Its Financial Infrastructure Caught Up?. Consumer protection is another part of the same problem.

Why the Merchant Refunded Me

My OpenAI experience was not the first time I had disputed an online payment.

I had previously faced an unauthorized transaction involving WordPress.com. I approached my bank, but the refund eventually came from WordPress.com.

I appreciated the merchant’s response.

The repetition bothered me.

On two occasions, I had turned to an overseas company to recover disputed payments after failing to obtain a satisfactory resolution through my Pakistani bank.

I cannot establish from these experiences that the bank failed to carry out an internal investigation. Nor does a merchant’s decision to refund money prove that the bank violated a security regulation.

A merchant can refund a transaction for several reasons, including a commercial decision to resolve a dispute.

Banks have a different responsibility.

The institution issuing a credit card decides whether to approve a payment request. That decision involves authorization systems, risk checks and information supplied through the card-payment network.

Not every legitimate international card transaction requires an OTP.

Some transactions use 3-D Secure authentication without a visible challenge. Others involve stored card credentials or recurring-payment arrangements.

I have explained these technical differences in my earlier article, Your Pakistani Card Can Be Charged Without an OTP. Who Protects You When It Happens?.

The fact that I received no OTP does not, by itself, establish a security failure.

But I still wanted to understand the authorization route used for my disputed transactions.

Were the payments treated as ordinary online purchases? Did they use stored credentials? What checks were performed before the issuing bank approved them?

I did not have access to the underlying authorization records.

The bank and the card-payment network hold information that a customer cannot obtain merely by examining a transaction alert.

A useful complaint response should address the evidence relevant to the disputed transaction.

A notification saying that a complaint has been closed does not explain how the bank reached its decision.

I have written separately about the steps available when a bank closes a complaint in Bank Closed Your Complaint? How to Challenge Disputed Card Charges in Pakistan.

The State Bank Already Has Consumer-Protection Rules

When I first considered writing about my experience, I was inclined to blame the State Bank of Pakistan for failing to pay enough attention to digital-payment security.

Then I examined its regulations.

The position was more complicated.

On 14 April 2023, SBP issued Circular No. 04, requiring banks and microfinance banks to strengthen controls against digital banking fraud.

It required implementation plans and monthly progress reporting.

The circular also contained a compensation provision. Banks that failed to implement the prescribed controls within the stipulated period could become liable to compensate victims within three working days of a fraud report, apart from possible enforcement action.

That provision is conditional. It cannot be treated as an automatic three-day refund guarantee for every disputed international credit-card payment.

A more relevant development came on 17 October 2025.

SBP issued its Business Conduct and Fair Treatment of Consumers Regulatory Framework, introducing detailed requirements for how financial institutions should treat customers and handle complaints.

I found its credit-card dispute provisions particularly interesting.

Banks must deal with disputed credit-card transactions according to the applicable rules of Visa, Mastercard or other international card networks.

During the investigation, the framework restricts the charging of mark-up on the disputed amount. If the bank decides the dispute in its own favour, it must provide the customer with related evidence without charging for it.

The framework also requires banks to explain complaint rejections.

A final rejection must include the reasons or evidence supporting the decision and information about the available alternative complaint forum.

Final responses must be communicated in writing, not merely through telephone calls.

These are specific obligations.

I would like to know how consistently banks follow them.

When a customer questions an overseas payment, the bank should give an explanation supported by the relevant records, subject to legitimate security and confidentiality limits.

The customer should not be expected to accept the mere fact that the transaction passed through an authorization system as proof that it was legitimate.

International card disputes also involve different timelines. SBP’s framework recognises the applicable vendor or card-network procedures, so the general 30-day fraud-complaint period does not necessarily determine when every international dispute must be settled.

There is another route for dissatisfied customers.

The Banking Mohtasib Pakistan provides an independent complaint forum for eligible disputes involving commercial banks.

Following a 2024 legal amendment, banks generally have 30 days to respond to a customer’s complaint before the matter can proceed under the statutory escalation procedure.

Pakistan has established consumer-protection mechanisms.

My concern is whether those mechanisms consistently provide the explanations and remedies that customers need.

The Numbers Pakistan Should Publish

I examined the Banking Mohtasib’s published figures.

They show that Pakistani customers do receive relief through the complaint system.

According to its 2025 annual report, the institution disposed of 36,280 complaints and reported monetary relief of approximately Rs 1.88 billion for customers.

Its October 2026 newsletter also reported approximately Rs 1.2 billion in relief during the first nine months of 2026.

These results deserve recognition.

It would be unfair to claim that Pakistan has no functioning banking complaint system.

The difficulty lies in understanding particular categories of disputes.

The public figures I reviewed do not provide a clear, complete picture of how often customers successfully challenge unauthorized international card transactions, how long those cases take, or why issuing banks reject individual disputes.

I would like the State Bank to make such outcomes easier to examine.

For example, banks could publish consistent figures on reported card fraud and the proportion of disputes resolved in favour of customers.

They could disclose typical investigation times for international card transactions and the number of complaints escalated after an initial rejection.

The figures would need common definitions. Otherwise, comparisons between banks could be misleading.

A fraudulent bank transfer through a mobile app is not the same as a disputed recurring card payment. The mechanisms and available remedies may differ.

Public reporting should preserve those distinctions.

SBP already collects information about banking conduct and digital fraud. Greater transparency about complaint outcomes would help customers assess the protection offered by individual institutions.

It would also give regulators a better public measure of whether consumer protection is keeping pace with digital-payment growth.

I understand why the government celebrates rising transaction volumes. They show that people are adopting electronic payments.

But the number of transactions alone cannot tell us how well banks respond when something goes wrong.

A customer who loses confidence after a disputed payment may return to cash even when digital payments are more convenient.

That is a cost the government’s adoption statistics may not capture.

My Money Came Back. My Questions Remained

I received my refund from OpenAI.

I was pleased to recover the money, but the bank’s handling of my complaint left questions unanswered.

I still want to know how seven transactions I never authorized were approved and what checks took place before the payments went through.

My professional experience makes the uncertainty harder to ignore.

I know that international payments depend on well-defined procedures and that different institutions carry different responsibilities.

The systems used for cross-border bank transfers differ from those used for credit-card authorization. My work does not give me access to the private records of a card transaction.

But it has taught me the importance of following a payment through the system and identifying where a problem occurred.

When a customer reports an unauthorized transaction, a bank should apply that same discipline.

The government now wants Pakistanis to use electronic payments for more of their daily transactions.

I understand the reasoning. I also understand why a shopkeeper who has just started accepting digital payments might hesitate after hearing about unresolved fraud complaints.

Not everyone has the experience to challenge a bank’s response. Many customers will simply accept whatever explanation they receive.

I find myself in an unusual position.

I trust electronic payment technology enough to have worked with it for much of my professional life. Yet my own experience has made me less confident about what happens when an ordinary customer disputes a payment.

The next time this happens, I would prefer not to begin by writing to a company thousands of miles away.

I would rather receive a clear answer from the bank whose card I carry.

Muhammad Munaeem Jamal

The author has professional experience in international banking and payment operations. The disputed transactions described here are based on his personal experience and correspondence. The article does not establish that any named bank suffered a security breach or violated a regulatory requirement.

Sources and further reading

Leave a Reply