Pakistan’s Constitution excludes non-Muslims from national leadership. Indonesia allowed a Christian to govern Jakarta, but his 2017 election revealed how religion and ethnic prejudice can influence political power.
On September 27, 2016, Jakarta’s governor visited the Thousand Islands, a group of islands off the Indonesian capital.
Basuki Tjahaja Purnama, known as Ahok, was discussing local development projects when he referred to a verse from the Qur’an.
Ahok was a Christian of Chinese descent. He was seeking another term as governor of a city where most voters were Muslim.
Within days, his remarks had become a national controversy. Religious organisations accused him of insulting Islam. Thousands gathered in Jakarta to demand action against him.
Seven months later, Ahok lost the election.
On May 9, 2017, an Indonesian court sentenced him to two years in prison for blasphemy.
I returned to this case after Brett Langridge commented on my recent article about Pakistan’s constitutional restrictions on non-Muslim leaders.
Brett remembered a Christian politician in Indonesia who had faced strong religious opposition. His recollection was not entirely accurate, but the incident deserved another look.
Pakistan and Indonesia offer an unusual comparison.
Pakistan’s Constitution prevents non-Muslims from becoming President or Prime Minister. Indonesia has no equivalent Muslim-only constitutional requirement for its presidency.
Ahok had already become governor of Jakarta.
What happened to him tells us something that constitutional provisions alone cannot explain.
Indonesia Had Already Accepted a Christian Governor
Ahok entered Jakarta’s government through an ordinary election.
In 2012, voters elected him deputy governor alongside Joko Widodo, popularly known as Jokowi.
When Jokowi became President of Indonesia in 2014, Ahok succeeded him as governor.
His religion did not disqualify him from holding that office.
Indonesia is the world’s largest Muslim-majority country, but its constitutional system differs from Pakistan’s.
Its founding philosophy, Pancasila, recognizes belief in one Almighty God. Article 29 of the Indonesian Constitution guarantees freedom of religion and worship.
Article 6 establishes qualifications for presidential candidates, including citizenship from birth and fitness for office. Additional conditions appear in election legislation.
Neither the Constitution nor those qualifications impose a general requirement that a presidential candidate must be Muslim.
Indonesia is not secular in precisely the American sense. Religion has a recognized place in its public institutions.
But an Indonesian Christian is not constitutionally excluded from the presidency merely for being Christian.
Ahok’s rise to the governorship showed that non-Muslims could occupy prominent political positions.
His reelection campaign exposed another difficulty.
How a Qur’anic Verse Became an Election Weapon
During his September 2016 visit, Ahok referred to Surah Al-Maidah, verse 51.
The verse has been used by some religious figures to argue that Muslims should not elect non-Muslim leaders. Its interpretation, particularly the meaning of the Arabic word awliya, has been debated.
Ahok suggested that political opponents were using the verse to discourage Muslim voters from supporting him.
On October 6, Buni Yani shared a shortened video of the speech on Facebook.
The accompanying text omitted the Indonesian word pakai, meaning “using.”
The omission mattered.
Ahok had criticized people who used a Qur’anic verse to influence voters. The accompanying text made his statement appear to accuse the verse itself of misleading people.
Buni Yani later argued through his lawyers that the text was a summary mixed with his opinion, not a literal transcript.
The controversy had already spread.
Conservative Islamic organizations organized large demonstrations. The Indonesian Ulema Council issued a religious opinion condemning Ahok’s remarks.
Ahok apologized to those who felt offended and denied intending to insult Islam.
The dispute eventually reached the courts.
I find one aspect of the episode especially troubling.
A governor was entitled to challenge the political use of religious teachings. His opponents were equally entitled to question his judgment and criticize his words.
But the controversy had moved beyond a disagreement over electoral policies.
Ahok’s religious identity became part of an accusation that eventually brought criminal prosecution.
Ahok Lost, but His Religion Does Not Explain Everything
Jakarta held its gubernatorial runoff election on April 19, 2017.
The official results were:
| Candidates | Votes | Share |
|---|---|---|
| Anies Baswedan and Sandiaga Uno | 3,240,987 | 57.96% |
| Ahok and Djarot Saiful Hidayat | 2,350,366 | 42.04% |
More than 2.3 million people voted for Ahok. The official election announcement confirmed the result.
That figure matters. A substantial part of Jakarta’s electorate supported a Christian governor despite the religious controversy.
Ahok was also a controversial administrator.
He had pursued infrastructure improvements and measures to address Jakarta’s flooding problems. His government ordered evictions from settlements along waterways and other areas targeted for redevelopment.
Residents who lost their homes challenged those policies. Some accused his administration of ignoring their livelihoods.
Ahok defended the evictions as necessary for flood control and urban development.
His blunt manner also irritated political opponents.
These were genuine political disputes. A voter could oppose Ahok’s policies without holding any prejudice against Christians.
Religion nevertheless played a visible role in the election campaign.
Then I came across research that complicated the explanation further.
The Research Found a Stronger Ethnic Factor
In April 2021, political scientist Nathanael Gratias Sumaktoyo published a study in the Journal of East Asian Studies.
He examined whether Ahok’s Christian religion or Chinese ethnicity had a greater influence on opposition among Jakarta’s Muslim voters.
His research used a survey conducted in November and early December 2016.
Researchers interviewed 1,195 Jakarta residents, including 1,047 Muslims.
The survey included experiments designed to examine how references to Ahok’s identity affected voter attitudes.
The results were revealing.
When Muslim respondents were reminded of Ahok’s Chinese ethnicity, their willingness to support him declined.
Reminding them of his Christian religion did not produce a statistically significant decline in the same experiment.
The researcher also examined respondents’ attitudes towards Christians and ethnic Chinese people.
Negative feelings towards ethnic Chinese people were more strongly associated with opposition to Ahok than negative feelings towards Christians, after accounting for other factors.
That is not what I expected from an election remembered largely for religious demonstrations.
Indonesia has a long history of tension involving its ethnic Chinese minority.
Under President Suharto, discriminatory policies restricted expressions of Chinese cultural identity. The violence of 1998 also left painful memories.
Ahok carried that history into politics.
His Christian identity was visible during the demonstrations, but his Chinese ancestry may have shaped voter attitudes in ways that public arguments about religion did not fully reveal.
The study has limits.
It was conducted before the April 2017 election. It cannot establish why each voter made a particular choice, nor can its experimental findings explain the complete election result.
The researcher did not conclude that religion was irrelevant.
Muslim respondents were less likely than non-Muslim respondents to support Ahok. Religious organizations also played a major role in mobilizing opposition.
But the evidence suggests that the candidate’s ethnicity had a stronger influence than his religion in the study’s analysis.
That distinction changes how I understand the campaign.
A religious controversy can dominate public discussion while older ethnic prejudices influence political choices beneath the surface.
The Blasphemy Verdict Was More Than an Electoral Defeat
Ahok lost the election, but his legal problems continued.
On May 9, 2017, the North Jakarta District Court convicted him of blasphemy under Article 156a of Indonesia’s Criminal Code.
The judges imposed a two-year prison sentence.
The outcome was harsher than prosecutors had recommended.
Prosecutors had dropped the blasphemy charge from their sentencing demand and sought punishment on a lesser charge involving insults towards a group. They recommended a suspended sentence.
The judges rejected that recommendation.
Amnesty International condemned the verdict and called for the repeal of Indonesia’s blasphemy law.
The organisation argued that peaceful expression about religion should not become grounds for imprisonment.
The sequence deserves attention.
Ahok had lawfully become governor. He contested another election and lost. Three weeks later, the criminal case arising from his campaign controversy resulted in imprisonment.
The Constitution had permitted him to govern.
It could not prevent religious accusations from becoming part of an electoral struggle and a criminal prosecution.
Pakistan Has Already Written the Barrier Into Its Constitution
In my earlier article, Why Can a Muslim Become President of America, but a Christian Cannot Become President of Pakistan?, I examined two provisions of Pakistan’s Constitution.
Under Article 41(2), Pakistan’s President must be Muslim.
Article 91(3) requires the National Assembly to elect the Prime Minister from among its Muslim members.
A Pakistani Christian may become a member of Parliament and serve as a federal minister.
But that citizen cannot become President or Prime Minister while remaining Christian.
The constitutional restriction applies regardless of political experience or public support.
Pakistan’s position has a historical explanation.
The country emerged from a political movement built around Muslim identity. Its Constitution recognizes Islam as the state religion and gives Islamic principles a formal role in public life.
Supporters of the religious qualifications believe the highest national offices should reflect that identity.
Many classical Muslim jurists also required the supreme ruler of an Islamic state to be Muslim.
The historical argument deserves serious examination. I explored the relationship between Islamic teachings and state institutions in The Qur’an Gives Principles of Government. Who Designed the State?
But I remain unconvinced that preserving an Islamic constitutional identity requires excluding non-Muslims from national leadership.
Pakistan already allows non-Muslims to serve in important public offices.
A Christian Prime Minister would still operate under Pakistan’s Constitution. Parliament would retain its authority, and the courts would continue to exercise their constitutional functions.
The Prime Minister’s religious identity would not, by itself, alter the country’s legal structure.
Pakistan and Indonesia have made different constitutional choices.
Indonesia permitted Ahok to govern Jakarta. His experience exposed the effects of religious mobilization and ethnic prejudice during a competitive election.
Pakistan’s Constitution prevents non-Muslims from seeking its highest national offices while retaining their faith.
The legal arrangements differ. So do the political obstacles.
What Brett’s Comment Made Me Reconsider
I initially thought Brett’s Indonesia example would simply reinforce my earlier argument about Pakistan.
The details changed my view.
Ahok had governed Jakarta for more than two years before the 2017 election.
Millions supported his reelection. Others opposed him for reasons that included his policies.
Religious organizations mobilized against him, while academic research found that his Chinese ancestry also influenced voter attitudes.
His defeat was followed by a prison sentence.
That experience cannot be described as a simple refusal by Indonesian Muslims to accept a Christian politician.
The political reality was more complicated.
I still believe citizens should be judged by their conduct and qualifications rather than excluded because of their religion.
But Ahok’s story shows that removing a legal restriction does not automatically remove prejudice from politics.
Pakistan’s problem begins earlier.
A Christian Pakistani cannot become President or Prime Minister under the present Constitution while remaining Christian. The election process cannot overcome that restriction.
Ahok faced no equivalent constitutional barrier to becoming Jakarta’s governor.
I looked again at the election result: 2,350,366 votes.
That was not enough to reelect him. But those voters had been free to support a Christian candidate, and many did.
In Pakistan, a Christian candidate cannot even enter the contest for the presidency on the same terms.
Medium republication details
Medium subtitle: Pakistan’s Constitution excludes non-Muslims from national leadership. Indonesia allowed a Christian to govern Jakarta, but his 2017 election revealed how religion and ethnic prejudice can influence political power.
Medium tags: Indonesia, Pakistan, Religious Freedom, Constitutional Law, Political Discrimination