Professional drivers learned complicated machinery through practice. New research raises an awkward question about the way modern dashboards are designed.
Billy Jones drove trucks for years. He remembers dashboards crowded with gauges and switches, along with manual transmissions that demanded considerable skill.
He also remembers knowing where everything was.
Within a few days of driving a truck, Billy says, he could find most controls without looking away from the road. He learned their positions while keeping track of traffic and the movement of a much larger vehicle.
Billy left that observation beneath my article about modern car touchscreens.
I had been examining why manufacturers were restoring physical buttons after years of removing them. Billy approached the matter from his working life.
His old trucks were complicated machines. Yet he found their controls easier to use than some of the screens in modern cars.
That sounds contradictory until we consider what makes a machine difficult to operate.
A Truck Driver’s Dashboard Was a Workplace
An older American long-haul truck could have separate gauges for oil pressure and air pressure. Switches controlled lighting or other vehicle equipment.
Depending on its configuration, the truck might also have auxiliary transmission controls or equipment associated with lift axles.
The driver needed to understand these systems. Billy remembers operating complex manual transmissions, managing additional controls and cancelling turn signals by hand.
I would not treat his recollection as proof that older trucks were safer. Modern commercial vehicles have benefited from significant improvements in braking and crash protection.
But the way professional drivers learn their equipment deserves attention.
A driver uses certain controls every working day. The position of a switch becomes familiar, as does the effort required to operate it.
The person may still have to check a gauge or look at an unfamiliar control. Physical equipment does not eliminate distraction.
What repeated practice can do is reduce the effort needed to perform familiar actions.
A truck might take time to learn. Once learned, however, many operations could become routine.
The Road Already Demands Constant Attention
Professional drivers have to look much further ahead than many motorists realise.
The Federal Motor Carrier Safety Administration’s commercial driving guidance advises drivers to scan roughly 12 to 15 seconds ahead.
At highway speed, that can mean watching traffic approximately a quarter of a mile away.
The driver must also pay attention to vehicles nearby.
FMCSA’s guidance on inadequate surveillance recommends checking mirrors at least every five to eight seconds, particularly when preparing to change lanes or turn.
These instructions describe different activities. Looking fifteen seconds ahead does not mean spending fifteen seconds staring at a single point.
Billy describes monitoring bridge heights and highway signs that ordinary motorists might overlook.
Such observations are part of operating a heavy vehicle safely.
Now consider what happens when a driver needs to adjust a setting inside the cab.
The control should not demand more attention than necessary.
A driver already monitoring surrounding traffic has little reason to welcome a system that requires several additional steps to complete an ordinary task.
Federal Researchers Identified the Problem Years Ago
The Federal Highway Administration studied how commercial drivers interacted with advanced traveller-information systems.
Its research examined tasks such as retrieving routing information and monitoring vehicle information while driving.
One finding stands out.
In the systems tested, the number of control actions had a greater effect on driver performance than the amount of information displayed.
Tasks requiring more than three control actions were associated with longer response times and poorer driving performance.
The FHWA consequently recommended that critical individual tasks in these commercial-driver systems should require no more than three control actions.
That recommendation needs context.
The experiments involved particular information systems and relatively simple tasks. They did not establish a universal rule for every switch or screen fitted to a vehicle.
The researchers also acknowledged that some tasks might reasonably require more operations when drivers could safely return their attention to the road between actions.
Still, I find the result revealing.
The researchers were examining the workload created by operating a system, not merely counting how many controls appeared on a dashboard.
That brings us back to Billy.
An older truck might contain fifty switches. If a driver could operate a familiar function with one movement, the number of other switches did not necessarily make that action difficult.
A newer interface might show only a handful of icons. Reaching the same function could require several selections.
The dashboard looks less complicated. The task has become longer.
A Clean Dashboard Can Conceal More Work
Picture two cars parked beside one another.
The first has a row of climate-control buttons and a rotary fan switch.
The second has a large screen with almost no physical controls beneath it.
The newer dashboard may look attractive. Its designers have removed much of the visible clutter.
But appearance does not tell us how much work a driver must perform.
In the first car, increasing the fan speed requires turning a knob.
In the second, the driver may need to open the climate menu before changing the setting.
The exact number of steps depends on the vehicle. Some modern screens keep climate controls permanently visible.
That qualification matters.
A well-designed touchscreen can provide direct access to frequently used functions. A poorly positioned physical switch can also be difficult to operate.
The important question is how quickly and reliably someone can complete the task while driving.
I would like manufacturers to publish more evidence about that rather than relying on showroom appeal.
Modern Truck Drivers Are Making Similar Complaints
Billy’s account might be dismissed as nostalgia if professional drivers were satisfied with today’s digital controls.
Research suggests a more complicated picture.
In March 2026, researchers published a study of adaptive interfaces in commercial trucks.
They conducted three exploratory focus groups involving nineteen participants drawn from professional drivers and industry experts.
The researchers wanted to identify problems with existing interfaces and examine possible improvements.
Complex menu structures emerged as a major concern.
Participants discussed the difficulty of locating functions inside nested menus. Some professional drivers wanted physical buttons that they could customise for frequently used tasks.
Their suggestions were practical.
A driver might want immediate access to radio controls or a particular vehicle function without having to move through several screens.
Industry experts also proposed interfaces that could learn drivers’ routines and adapt accordingly.
Not everyone welcomed that possibility.
Participants raised concerns about technology making decisions for them and reducing their control over the interface.
The study was small and exploratory. Nineteen participants cannot represent the preferences of every professional truck driver.
But the findings show that complicated digital menus remain a problem even in vehicles operated by trained professionals.
Billy’s complaint has not disappeared with the older generation of trucks.
Familiarity Is Useful, but It Cannot Solve Poor Design
There is an interesting difference between learning a control and learning a menu.
A physical switch generally occupies one position.
After repeated use, a driver may learn its location and movement. The hand receives some information from the shape and resistance of the control.
A touchscreen can change what appears in the same physical space.
The driver may have to identify the correct icon before performing an action. A software update might also move a function to a different location.
In August 2026, researchers published a simulator study comparing physical controls with touchscreen controls for driving-related tasks.
They found greater visual distraction associated with touchscreen use across the tasks examined.
For tasks requiring multiple interactions, touchscreen use also produced poorer task and driving performance.
The researchers made a small change to the touchscreen layout during testing.
That change disrupted performance on the first task after the rearrangement.
The study involved thirty-two participants in a simulator. Its findings cannot establish how many crashes are caused by touchscreen controls on public roads.
But they help explain the value of stable control positions.
Familiarity reduces searching only when the driver can rely on what has been learned.
Billy knew where his switches were.
If the location of a frequently used control changed from one journey to another, that knowledge would become less useful.
Digital Controls Are Not Always Inferior
The argument needs another qualification.
In 2022, researchers conducted a study involving twenty-three truck drivers to compare different approaches to cockpit controls.
They tested physical buttons with small displays, buttons with integrated displays and a touchscreen offering haptic feedback.
The study found relatively small differences in operating safety between the tested approaches. Acceptance ratings did not differ significantly.
That result does not prove every touchscreen performs as well as a physical switch.
It shows that interface design matters more than a simple division between old and new technologies.
A touchscreen with useful feedback may perform better than one that offers none.
A control placed within easy reach may be more practical than a physical button hidden behind the steering wheel.
The functions themselves also differ.
A navigation map needs visual space. A switch for a frequently used driving function benefits from easy access.
Manufacturers should design around the task.
I would rather see evidence from actual use than another argument about whether drivers are old-fashioned for wanting buttons.
Real Driving Data Adds Another Perspective
A July 2026 study examined how motorists interacted with in-vehicle information systems during everyday journeys.
The researchers analysed data from 669,493 trips across seventy-nine countries.
They found that drivers interacted with these systems approximately every five minutes on average.
Physical-button interactions occurred more frequently than touchscreen interactions in the vehicles studied.
That does not establish a universal preference for buttons.
Different controls perform different jobs. A driver might use steering-wheel buttons repeatedly while opening a navigation menu only once during a journey.
The study also involved a particular collection of vehicles and their installed interfaces.
Nevertheless, it provides a useful reminder.
The ordinary tasks drivers perform repeatedly deserve close attention.
A manufacturer may spend considerable effort designing an impressive central display. Buyers will spend years operating the smaller controls around it.
The two experiences should not be confused.
What Car Designers Could Learn From Professional Drivers
I would begin by watching how experienced operators use their equipment.
Which controls do they reach for most often?
How much visual attention does each action require? Can the driver complete the task through touch, or must the person search a display?
I would also observe what happens when a driver moves into an unfamiliar vehicle.
A system that works beautifully after months of practice may be frustrating during the first week.
Professional truck drivers receive training and develop routines. Passenger-car owners often receive little instruction beyond a brief demonstration at the dealership.
A car’s controls should account for that difference.
The FHWA research suggests that reducing unnecessary control actions is a worthwhile design goal.
The 2026 truck-driver study adds another lesson: people who use complex machinery professionally want interfaces that respect their routines.
That may mean a physical switch for one function and a digital display for another.
The right answer need not look the same on every dashboard.
The Switch Billy Could Find Without Looking
I keep returning to Billy’s description of those older trucks.
He had to understand equipment that most passenger-car owners would never encounter. He also had to manage the road ahead while operating it.
The machinery demanded skill. It was not necessarily easy.
Yet the controls he used regularly became familiar through practice.
Modern carmakers have removed many visible switches in the name of simpler design.
Some changes have improved the driving experience. Others have left drivers searching through menus for functions they once found by touch.
A dashboard does not become easier to operate merely because it looks less crowded.
Billy could reach for a switch and know where his hand was going.
I would like car designers to explain why a driver should now need a screen to perform that same kind of task.