Tonight, an old WhatsApp group took me back to Libya in 1971.
The group belongs to former colleagues from AEG Pakistan. Many years have passed since we worked together, but the group remains active. Someone shares an old photograph. Someone sends a greeting. Politics inevitably finds its way in.
Tonight, someone posted a short video showing four Muslim leaders together. The caption claimed they had formed an alliance and were later killed.
The discussion started almost immediately.
One colleague pointed out that these men were not democrats. I replied that Saddam Hussein was a Ba’athist and reminded the group of his regime’s chemical attack on the Kurds at Halabja.
Then another former colleague wrote something that changed the conversation.
I knew him well. We worked together at AEG Pakistan for about a decade.
Before AEG, however, he had lived another life.
“My First Job Was in Libya”
He told us that his first job, from 1971 to 1974, was with Occidental Oil Company in Tripoli. His work took him into the Libyan desert on surveys connected with oil and drinking-water exploration.
Then he began describing the Libya he remembered.
Gaddafi was not democratic, he acknowledged. Yet my colleague remembered him as a young leader deeply committed to improving the country. Education, he said, was free, including educational materials. He also remembered state assistance with land and housing for poorer Libyans.
The broad historical picture fits Libya’s transformation under oil wealth: the state expanded education and public services, while literacy and access to schooling improved substantially over the following decades. The exact details of a housing programme remembered after more than fifty years deserve more caution. Memory does not preserve government regulations like an archive does.
But then my colleague described something no government archive could have given me.
When Someone Said “Muammar”
During his work in Libya, he talked with local people.
Sometimes Gaddafi’s first name came up.
“Muammar.”
My colleague remembers people bringing the fingers of their hands together, kissing them and then touching them to their eyes.
I read that part of his message twice.
I knew the kind of gesture he meant. We see similar expressions of affection and respect in our own part of the world. Suddenly I was no longer reading another WhatsApp argument about a dead Arab ruler.
I was listening to an old colleague describe people he had met when both he and Gaddafi were young.
My colleague’s experience cannot tell us what every Libyan thought. There were Libyans who opposed Gaddafi, and repression became a defining feature of his long rule.
Still, I hesitate to throw away an eyewitness memory merely because it does not fit comfortably into the history we learned later.
In 1971, Gaddafi had been in power for only two years. My colleague was seeing him near the beginning.
A Man in the Desert
He also remembers Gaddafi moving through desert areas and staying in tents.
That image followed Gaddafi for decades. His Bedouin-style tent eventually became almost as recognisable as his uniforms. He even took it abroad, sometimes leaving host governments wondering where they could accommodate it.
For my colleague, however, the tent was not yet international theatre. It belonged to the Libya in which he was working.
One detail in his recollection seems to come from a later period. He associates Gaddafi with the famous female guards who eventually surrounded him. Historical accounts generally place that distinctive security unit later, particularly from the 1980s.
Fifty years can move things around in memory. I don’t find that surprising. I sometimes struggle to place events from my own working life in their exact year. A face remains clear. A conversation survives. The calendar becomes less obedient.
WhatsApp Is a Bad Place for Fifty Years of History
The original video was only eleven seconds long.
That struck me afterwards.
A few seconds of old footage can carry an enormous claim. Someone adds a caption, forwards it to a group, and before long Saddam Hussein, Gaddafi and half a century of Middle Eastern history have been sorted into heroes and villains.
My colleague complicated that comfortable arrangement.
I have no wish to turn his memories into a defence of Gaddafi. Gaddafi ruled Libya without meaningful democratic accountability. His government suppressed political opposition. The security state could be brutal.
But I am equally uncomfortable pretending that schools, housing programmes or rising literacy cease to count because an authoritarian government provided them.
Libyans did experience material changes under Gaddafi. Oil revenues gave the state resources that an earlier, much poorer Libya had never possessed on the same scale. Some people evidently connected those changes personally with the man who ruled them.
My colleague remembers meeting such people. That is all his testimony needs to establish.
The Gaddafi He Could Not Yet Know
The young officer my colleague encountered from 1971 to 1974 would remain in power for decades. Nobody standing in that desert could see the whole road ahead.
There would be confrontation with Western governments, international isolation and sanctions. Libya would later return from that isolation for a time.
Then came 2011.
Protests developed into an armed uprising. Government forces fought rebels. NATO intervened after the UN Security Council authorised measures to protect civilians. Gaddafi’s government collapsed, and he was captured and killed near Sirte in October 2011.
But removing the ruler did not produce the stable democratic Libya many people hoped would follow. Armed factions competed for power, political authority fractured, and the country entered years of instability. I have written elsewhere about Britain’s role in the NATO operation in Libya, and Libya also appears in my discussion of how Iran reads the fate of states that gave up strategic deterrence.
None of that proves Gaddafi should have remained in power. It does make his country’s story harder to compress into an eleven-second WhatsApp video.
An Old Colleague’s Libya
What interests me now is how the whole thing reached me.
Not through a history book. Not through a documentary.
It came through an old company WhatsApp group.
A man with whom I spent about ten years at AEG Pakistan happened to see a forwarded video and remembered his first job. Suddenly the colleague I knew from Pakistan was a young man again, working for Occidental in Libya and travelling through the desert.
More than fifty years separated his memory from the message on my phone.
There are things I would verify before treating every detail as history. I would never use one man’s experience to tell Libyans what their country was like.
But I would not discard what he saw either.
I keep returning to one part of his message.
Someone says “Muammar.” My colleague remembers people kissing their fingertips and touching them to their eyes.
Tomorrow our AEG group will probably return to the usual forwards, greetings and arguments.
But tonight one message travelled much farther than the video that started the discussion.
It went back to Libya in 1971.