An empty classroom in Italy, illustrating the importance of protecting children's safety and education.

Italy Condemns Child Marriage. But Who Protects Girls From Sexual Exploitation?

In April 2026, Italian authorities expelled a Pakistani imam from Brescia after he defended marriage involving a nine-year-old girl. I oppose child marriage. But the report led me to a second question: what happens to teenagers sexually exploited in Italy by adults who offer affection or protection and then abuse their trust?

I am a father of two daughters. One completed her education after marriage and now works as a researcher in Munich. My daughter-in-law completed her PhD after marriage, supported by my wife. A religiously observant niece graduated from NED University in Karachi. I have seen marriage and education coexist when families support women’s ambitions. Those are experiences of supportive adult marriages, not evidence that child marriage is safe.

What happened in Brescia?

Corriere della Sera reported on April 3, 2026 that the authorities expelled Ali Kashif after remarks made during a television investigation. The expulsion was an administrative action, not a conviction for sexually abusing a child. Italy normally sets the marriage age at 18, with exceptional court authorisation possible from 16. Marriage at nine is not permitted.

His statement should be criticised without making one imam speak for every Muslim family. Italy’s own child-protection record also deserves scrutiny.

Online grooming and sexual extortion

Save the Children Italy reported police figures for 2025 showing 428 online grooming cases involving minors, up from 370 in 2024. Sexual extortion cases involving minors rose from 127 to 220. Of the 220 sexual extortion cases, 192 victims were aged 14 to 16.

An offender may gain a teenager’s confidence through messages, obtain an intimate image and threaten to distribute it. The threat can follow the child into school and home even when the offender lives elsewhere. Boys can also be victims. Recorded cases do not measure every incident, and online extortion should not be confused with commercial sex trafficking.

The wider combined count of cases involving child sexual abuse material and grooming actually fell, from 2,809 in 2024 to 2,574 in 2025. It would be misleading to claim that every indicator increased.

When an apparent boyfriend is a trafficker

The 2025 US Trafficking in Persons Report on Italy describes traffickers who approach girls with promises of romantic relationships. Social media can make the initial contact easier. A relationship that appears affectionate may become controlling through isolation, threats or dependence.

Unaccompanied migrant children face particular risks. A young person who needs accommodation or help with unfamiliar institutions can become dependent on someone offering assistance. Most offers of help are genuine. A trafficker exploits the situation to gain control.

The identification gap

The US report placed Italy in Tier 2: the government was making significant anti-trafficking efforts but did not fully meet the report’s minimum standards. In 2023, authorities formally identified 540 new trafficking victims, fewer than 2% of whom were children. That is an administrative count of identified victims, not a measure of how many children were actually exploited.

A child may first come to police attention through an immigration check or suspected offence. If an officer misses the signs of coercion, the child may be treated as a suspect rather than recognised as someone who needs protection. That is a practical institutional failure, not simply a problem of criminal law.

Italy has services, but do they reach the children?

Italy funds anti-trafficking assistance through public authorities and specialist organisations. The 2025 US report records €28.8 million allocated to projects running from March 2024 through August 2025. In 2023, government-funded programmes assisted 1,368 trafficking victims, including 750 who had experienced sex trafficking. These totals include adults and must not be labelled as numbers of exploited teenage girls.

Assistance can involve protected accommodation, legal help and counselling. Yet the report also describes shortcomings affecting vulnerable groups, including unaccompanied children. A programme can exist on paper while a teenager who needs it remains unidentified.

Save the Children’s Vie d’Uscita programme reached 1,345 beneficiaries in 2025 and identified 79 minors or newly adult people as victims of trafficking or exploitation. Sexual exploitation represented 19% of these identified cases; labour exploitation accounted for 65.8%. The programme also recorded three forced-marriage cases. These are programme findings, not nationwide prevalence figures.

Family support is not the same as child protection law

My daughter’s education continued after marriage. My daughter-in-law completed her doctorate with family help. I value that responsibility. But supportive marriages between adults cannot tell us whether a nine-year-old can freely choose marriage. A legal obligation placed on a husband is no substitute for a child’s ability to consent or obtain protection.

Sexual exploitation can occur inside or outside marriage. An online predator may never meet the child. A trafficker may promise love and then demand obedience. The important questions are the child’s age, the coercion involved and whether institutions can intervene.

What European monitors found

The Council of Europe’s GRETA evaluation of Italy acknowledged progress while raising concerns about identifying trafficking victims and their access to justice and compensation. A child may need safe housing and help returning to education while criminal proceedings continue.

Italy operates a national anti-trafficking helpline, 800 290 290. But a teenager controlled by an older partner may not recognise the abuse or may fear reporting it. Teachers, social workers and police need the training to identify exploitation without waiting for a frightened child to explain everything.

A question beyond the headline

I have written about related forms of exploitation elsewhere, including Romanian girls trafficked into Europe’s sex industry and online child sexual exploitation and social media in Pakistan. These are different settings, but they expose the same difficulty: an abused child may be invisible to the system designed to protect her.

The Brescia imam’s remarks attracted justified attention. Italy’s police data and international assessments raise a quieter question. How many children are not identified in time, and what would it take for a teacher, social worker or officer to recognise the danger before the harm deepens?

Leave a Reply