A broken road in Karachi can become a lesson in Pakistani federalism. Residents complain, the mayor faces questions, and then comes the harder issue: which institution controls the road and who has the money to repair it? I live in Karachi, where the Sindh government is based. Proximity to a provincial capital has not guaranteed effective municipal services.
Pakistan may need smaller provinces in some regions. Yet before redrawing its map, it should examine why power and public money so often stop at provincial capitals instead of reaching elected cities and districts.
Why Pakistan Is Talking About New Provinces Again
In November 2026, Interior Minister Mohsin Naqvi suggested a referendum on additional provinces or administrative units. Other ministers have discussed arrangements involving 12 or more provinces, but no agreed constitutional amendment or final map has been established. PPP chairman Bilawal Bhutto Zardari strongly opposes a forced division of Sindh and has warned of violence in Karachi.
Sindh’s identity and Karachi’s history of ethnic conflict make consent essential. But the PPP, which has governed Sindh since 2008, must also explain how much authority its laws give Karachi’s elected representatives.
Pakistan Decentralised Power, but Only Part of the Way
The Eighteenth Amendment in 2010 strengthened the provinces. The Seventh National Finance Commission Award increased their share of federal revenues. These reforms changed relations between Islamabad and provincial capitals. They did not create an equally strong fiscal position for local governments.
The World Bank’s 2026 work on fiscal federalism reports that local governments accounted for roughly 10% of total government expenditure in 2005, but less than 5% in 2024. These figures do not prove that the Eighteenth Amendment caused the decline. They do show how weak the local tier remains. The Bank also found that more than 80% of provincial spending in FY2023 went to recurrent costs.
Article 140A: The Constitutional Duty We Overlook
Article 160 provides a constitutional framework for federal-provincial revenue distribution. Article 140A requires each province to establish elected local government and devolve political, administrative and financial responsibility and authority. Yet it does not prescribe a nationwide municipal revenue formula comparable to the NFC. Provinces control much of the legislation and funding arrangements for their cities.
A province can demand autonomy from Islamabad while retaining considerable control over the budgets and decisions of municipalities. This is the unfinished part of Pakistan’s decentralisation.
Karachi’s Water Corporation Shows How Authority Is Divided
Karachi’s municipal responsibilities are split among the Karachi Metropolitan Corporation, town administrations, provincial agencies and institutions operating under separate laws. The Karachi Water and Sewerage Corporation Act, 2023 makes the elected mayor chair of its board, alongside provincial representation. It would be wrong to say the mayor has no formal role in water governance. It would be equally wrong to assume that chairing the board gives him personal control over every operational decision.
When a sewer overflows, residents should be able to identify the responsible institution, its repair budget and the official who can authorise the work. Dividing services between specialised agencies can be sensible. Dividing accountability until no one answers is not.
The Supreme Court Addressed Local Government Powers
In February 2022, the Supreme Court ruled on an MQM-P challenge concerning Sindh’s local government framework. It affirmed that Article 140A imposes a mandatory duty to establish meaningful elected local governments. The judgment did not give every municipal function to the mayor. It underscored the constitutional importance of genuine local authority.
Sindh’s October 2026 Amendment
Sindh’s 2026 local government amendment, published in the official Gazette on October 12, changed aspects of council administration. It made deputy mayors or vice-chairmen conveners of council meetings, introduced local reconciliation arrangements and addressed continuity when councils complete their terms. Such changes matter, but altered meeting procedures do not by themselves demonstrate broad fiscal devolution.
Pakistan Has Tried Devolution Before
General Pervez Musharraf’s 2001 devolution plan created elected district governments and strengthened district nazims. Some decisions moved closer to residents, but the scheme emerged under military rule and changed the balance between district and provincial elites. Pakistan should not romanticise military-led decentralisation. Nor should elected provincial governments be excused when they hesitate to transfer power to municipalities.
Why Provincial Politicians Retain Power
Provincial ministers and legislators gain influence from development budgets and administrative appointments. A mayor with predictable funding can make decisions independently and claim credit for improvements. That creates another elected centre of power. The political incentive to retain authority helps explain why local government reform has often remained unstable.
Smaller Provinces Could Still Help
Southern Punjab has a reasonable case for examining administrative restructuring. Balochistan’s vast territory and scattered population create other challenges. Smaller provinces could improve representation and access to senior officials. But a new province also requires an assembly, departments and agreements over assets, liabilities and revenues. No new boundary guarantees that its government will devolve power to cities.
A Referendum Cannot Replace Constitutional Consent
Article 239 requires a constitutional amendment to change provincial boundaries, including two-thirds approval in both houses of Parliament and two-thirds of the total membership of the affected provincial assembly. In Sindh’s 168-seat assembly, the threshold is 112 votes. Article 48(6) provides a referendum mechanism following the prescribed parliamentary process, but such a vote cannot replace Article 239.
Sindh’s political identity deserves respect. Bilawal may oppose a forced division while still being asked to explain how the province meets its duty to empower elected local government. Provincial autonomy and municipal autonomy need not conflict.
Follow the Money Before Drawing Another Map
Pakistan should publish the functions, budgets and actual spending of its municipal institutions. How much funding do local governments receive through predictable transfers? What can they raise or retain? Which provincial agencies manage services that residents associate with city government? The same questions apply to Punjab, Khyber Pakhtunkhwa and Balochistan.
Pakistan may eventually benefit from more provinces. But a new capital can become another distant centre of power if districts beneath it must still wait for permission and money. I return to Karachi’s roads. If someone redraws the boundary tomorrow, the essential question remains: Who controls the road, and who controls the money?
Sources and further reading
World Bank: Strengthening Fiscal Federalism in Pakistan; Sindh Local Government (Amendment) Act, 2026; Karachi Water and Sewerage Corporation Act, 2023; Supreme Court local government ruling coverage.
Related articles on Munaeem.org
Pakistan Does Not Lack Discipline. It Lacks a State That Does Its Job. and Pakistan Does Not Need Western Values to Demand Western Standards of Governance.