I live in Karachi, a city where traces of a vanished Jewish community still survive if you know where to look. Most Karachi residents pass through the city without thinking about the Jews who once lived here, traded here and prayed here. Their organised community largely disappeared decades ago.
Europe presents a very different history. Its Jewish communities did not simply vanish from public memory after the Holocaust. Europe built museums, memorials and laws around that catastrophe. German schoolchildren learn about Nazism. Auschwitz became one of the world’s most recognisable symbols of industrialised mass murder.
Yet antisemitism survived. That is the puzzle that interests me.
The usual explanation says Europe keeps forgetting its history. I think the history points towards something more complicated. Antisemitism has endured partly because it has proved remarkably adaptable. The accusation changes. The political vocabulary changes. The technology changes too. The target remains Jewish.
An Old Prejudice Learned New Languages
Medieval European antisemitism operated inside a predominantly Christian society. Jews faced restrictions on where they could live and what occupations they could enter. Authorities at different times barred them from owning land, joining certain trades or holding public positions. These restrictions pushed some Jewish communities towards commerce, currency exchange and moneylending.
Centuries later, the consequence was grotesquely reversed. Instead of recognising that institutions had restricted Jewish economic choices, antisemites turned Jewish participation in finance into evidence of supposed Jewish greed and secret economic power. I have examined some of these recurring ideas separately in The Murky Myths Behind Antisemitism.
The stereotype outlived the institutions that helped create it. Other accusations were even darker. During the Black Death, Jews were falsely accused of poisoning wells and causing the plague. Religious myths accused Jews of murdering Christian children. England expelled its Jewish population in 1290. Spain ordered practising Jews to convert or leave in 1492. The experience of Jews fleeing Christian Europe also forms part of the background to my earlier discussion of Jewish refuge in the Ottoman Empire.
None of this was modern racial antisemitism yet. That distinction matters.
European society changed profoundly during the Enlightenment and the nineteenth century. Religious authority weakened in many places. Citizenship expanded. Science acquired enormous prestige. Antisemitism adapted. Jews could now be portrayed not merely as followers of the wrong religion but as members of an allegedly dangerous race. Conversion to Christianity could not solve a racial accusation because ancestry itself had become the supposed problem.
The language had changed from theology to pseudoscience. The prejudice survived the transition.
Auschwitz Did Not Erase What Came Before It
Nazi Germany carried racial antisemitism to its catastrophic conclusion. Six million Jews were murdered during the Holocaust. After 1945, European governments confronted a continent in which centuries of prejudice had culminated in systematic extermination.
Something genuinely changed after the war. Open antisemitism became socially and politically unacceptable across much of Western Europe. Germany eventually constructed an extensive culture of remembrance. European institutions developed laws against racial discrimination and incitement.
It would be comforting to stop the story there. Current evidence does not allow it.
The EU Agency for Fundamental Rights surveyed Jewish people in 13 EU countries before the Hamas attacks of October 2023. Those countries account for around 96 percent of the EU’s Jewish population. Among respondents, 80 percent said antisemitism had increased in their country during the previous five years. Some 91 percent regarded antisemitism on the internet and social media as a major problem, while 96 percent said they had encountered antisemitism during the previous year.
The timing matters. The survey ended before October 7, 2023 and Israel’s subsequent military response in Gaza. It therefore cannot be used as a measurement of the effect of that war. FRA later consulted Jewish umbrella organisations, some of which reported increases of 400 percent or more in recorded antisemitic incidents. That does not mean antisemitism increased by 400 percent across Europe: reporting systems and baselines differ.
Still, something serious was happening before October 7. The conflict appears to have intensified an existing problem rather than created one from nothing. My earlier report on antisemitic incidents in Britain, France and Germany after the Hamas attack captured the immediate anxiety of that period.
What Happens When Living Memory Disappears?
Europe is entering a period that deserves more attention. The generation that personally remembers the Holocaust is disappearing.
For decades, survivors could walk into classrooms and describe what happened to them. Their presence collapsed historical distance. A concentration camp was not merely a paragraph in a textbook when someone sitting in front of students could describe arriving there.
That form of memory cannot continue indefinitely. The European Commission’s 2026 Eurobarometer on perceptions of antisemitism offers an uncomfortable snapshot. Only 48 percent of Europeans said they thought the Holocaust was sufficiently taught in schools. Only about one in three believed people in their country were well informed about Jewish history and culture.
I would resist an easy conclusion here. Those numbers do not prove that weaker Holocaust education causes antisemitism. History rarely offers such a clean causal chain. But they expose a vulnerability. When living memory disappears, institutions must carry more of the burden.
Then Came October 7 and Gaza
The Israel-Palestine conflict has made the boundary between political argument and antisemitism particularly contested.
Criticising an Israeli government is not inherently antisemitic. Opposing settlement policy is not inherently antisemitic. Condemning Israeli military conduct in Gaza is not inherently antisemitic either. Israelis themselves fiercely debate their governments and policies.
The problem begins somewhere else. It begins when responsibility assigned to a state or government becomes collective responsibility imposed on Jews. A Jewish shopkeeper in Paris does not determine Israeli military policy. A Jewish student in Berlin does not become responsible for decisions taken by Israel’s cabinet. This distinction is central to my earlier article on why Jewish people should not be blamed collectively for actions of the Israeli government.
The 2026 Eurobarometer found that 69 percent of Europeans believe conflicts in the Middle East influence perceptions of Jewish people in their country, up 15 percentage points from the comparable 2018 survey. The number does not tell us that everyone influenced in this way becomes antisemitic. It tells us that Europeans themselves perceive a connection between a distant geopolitical conflict and attitudes towards Jewish neighbours at home.
The opposite error also matters. If every criticism of Israel is automatically labelled antisemitic, the term loses analytical precision and legitimate political debate becomes harder. Europe therefore faces two tasks at once: protecting Jews from hatred while preserving space for robust criticism of governments, including Israel’s.
The Internet Gave an Ancient Prejudice New Machinery
I sometimes think the most important change is not ideological at all. It is technological.
A medieval rumour travelled through markets, churches and taverns. A twentieth-century conspiracy required pamphlets, newspapers or radio. A twenty-first-century conspiracy needs a smartphone.
FRA found that 91 percent of Jewish respondents regarded antisemitism online and on social media as a major problem. The conspiracy theories themselves can look remarkably old: claims that Jews secretly control banks, governments or the media have repeatedly resurfaced in different forms. The distribution system is new. Much of the underlying mythology is not.
The Far Right Is Part of the Story, Not the Whole Story
It is tempting to put contemporary European antisemitism into one ideological box. That would be convenient. It would also be inaccurate.
Far-right and neo-Nazi movements have long carried antisemitic ideas. But antisemitism can also emerge through Islamist extremism, conspiracy subcultures that do not fit comfortably into traditional left-right categories, and political spaces where opposition to Israel crosses into hostility towards Jews collectively. These sources are not identical. Their motives and political histories differ.
The Council of the European Union in 2024 called for stronger action against antisemitic hate speech and greater protection of Jewish people and institutions. The security question is not abstract. I wrote about it during the tense weeks after October 7 in Where Can Jews Still Feel Safe? The broader institutional response is explored in my earlier examination of EU and US initiatives against antisemitism.
Protecting Jewish Europeans should not require minimising hatred directed at Muslims, migrants or other minorities. A democratic state can investigate each phenomenon on its own evidence.
There Is No Single European Experience
Another mistake bothers me when I read discussions of this subject. We speak of “Europe” as though Stockholm, Paris and Tallinn were one society. They are not.
The 2026 Eurobarometer exposes the difference. Across the EU, 55 percent of respondents considered antisemitism a problem in their country. In France the figure was 74 percent; Italy and Sweden recorded 73 percent. Estonia recorded 9 percent, Finland 16 percent and Latvia 19 percent.
Those numbers measure public perceptions, not the objective prevalence of antisemitism. Still, the variation warns against sweeping continental claims. Europe contains different Jewish populations, different memories of the Second World War and different contemporary political conflicts.
Perhaps “Returning” Is the Wrong Word
I began with a question: why does antisemitism keep returning to Europe?
After looking again at the history, I am no longer sure “returning” is the most accurate word. Something that returns must first have gone away. Antisemitism did not.
Its public acceptability changed. Its vocabulary changed dramatically. Governments that once discriminated against Jews now prosecute antisemitic offences and protect synagogues. Those changes are real and important.
But prejudices can survive political transformation by finding new explanations for themselves. Medieval Europe could portray Jews as religious enemies. Racial nationalists could describe them as biological outsiders. Conspiracy theorists could imagine hidden financial control. Today an argument about Israel can sometimes become an accusation against Jews thousands of kilometres away.
The continuity does not mean every historical form is equivalent. It means an old prejudice has repeatedly learned how to speak the language of a new age.
From Karachi, I find that more unsettling than the idea of history simply repeating itself. History rarely repeats so neatly.
Sometimes it survives by changing clothes.
One thought on “Why Antisemitism Keeps Returning to Europe”